Dump it in. Walk away. 20 free high-protein crockpot dinners + 3 bonus breakfasts.

All recipes

Free ebook

Dump & Go Comfort Food

20 high-protein keto crockpot dinners with freezer packs, plus 3 bonus breakfasts and a two-week plan. Dump it in. Walk away.

You'll also get one new dinner by email every Sunday. Unsubscribe anytime.

Creamy Italian Meatball Soup

One-pot creamy tomato soup with beef meatballs, ditalini, parmesan and spinach.

This post has affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure

Creamy Italian Meatball Soup
01Why this one

Creamy Italian meatball soup, but no spaghetti. One pot, a pound of beef meatballs, a cup of little ditalini tubes and a tomato broth that turns creamy orange the second the cream goes in.

Here’s the build. A diced onion and three cloves of garlic in olive oil. Two tablespoons of tomato paste dropped right in the middle and pushed around the pot until it coats everything. Six cups of broth and a teaspoon of Italian seasoning poured over the top, then the meatballs and the ditalini together. Ten minutes of simmering and the pasta is tender. Then a cup of cream swirls through the red broth in white ribbons, half a cup of parmesan snows down over it, and three cups of spinach wilt in last.

Every spoonful catches a meatball, a few tubes of pasta and a green ribbon of spinach. Simple can still be unforgettable.

The tomato paste minute

Most of this soup’s flavor comes from one minute that’s easy to rush. When the tomato paste hits the onion and garlic, don’t just stir it in and move on. Spread it across the bottom of the pot and keep it moving for a full minute. It darkens from bright red to brick and starts to stick. That’s the same browning that happens when a steak hits a hot grill, and it’s what makes the broth taste rich instead of thin and tinny.

Then pour in the broth and scrape the bottom. All that toasted paste lifts off and turns the broth a deep red.

Why ditalini

Ditalini means “little thimbles” in Italian, and they’re the classic soup pasta for a reason. They’re small enough to fit on a spoon with a meatball, they cook in about the same 10 minutes the meatballs need to heat through, and they hold their shape in the broth. Long noodles would turn this into a different soup entirely. We have that one too, and it’s called spaghetti and meatball soup.

The cream finish

Turn the heat down to low before the cream goes in. A hard boil can split it. Pour the cup of cream in a slow circle and watch it swirl through the red broth until the whole pot turns a soft, creamy orange. Sprinkle the parmesan across the surface and stir until it melts away.

The spinach looks like way too much when it’s piled on top. Push it under and stir. In about a minute, three cups shrink down to dark green ribbons. Taste before you add salt; the parmesan and broth bring plenty.

If you love a creamy tomato soup, my creamy Tuscan chicken soup is the chicken version of this idea. And for a game day pot that feeds a crowd, my keto beef cheeseburger soup is the one I’d put on next.

Built on protein

This isn’t a low carb soup. The ditalini stay, because a meatball needs some pasta beside it on the spoon. What carries it is a full pound of beef meatballs plus the parmesan, which brings each bowl to about 19 g of protein per serving. One cup of dry ditalini for six bowls keeps it a soup, not a pasta dish.

02Before you cook

Easy swaps

  • Use homemade mini beef meatballs, browned first.
  • Swap the ditalini for small shells or orzo; keep the same 1 cup.
  • Use half-and-half for a lighter broth.
  • Use chopped kale instead of spinach and give it 2 extra minutes.
03At the stove
Creamy Italian Meatball Soup
The recipe

Creamy Italian Meatball Soup

Prep
10 MIN
Cook
20 MIN
Total
30 MIN
Serves
6

01Ingredients

6 bowls

03Method

Tap a step when it's done. The next one lights up.

0 OF 4 DONE

04Recipe notes

  1. 01The pasta thickens the soup as it sits. Loosen leftovers with a splash of broth and reheat to 165°F.

05Nutrition

Per serving
Calories
507
Protein
19G
Net carbs
24G
Fat
37G
Fiber
3G

Net carbs are total carbs minus fiber. Numbers are estimates from the ingredients listed.

Made it?

How did it turn out?

No ratings yet. Tap a star to be the first.

Snap a photo and tag @recipe_smoke1 so I can see how yours came out.

04After dinner

Make ahead, storing and reheating

The ditalini keeps drinking up broth overnight, so leftovers come out thick. Keep the soup covered in the fridge for 3 to 4 days and add a splash of broth when you reheat it. Warm it over medium-low heat until it’s steaming and reaches 165°F, as the USDA’s guide to leftovers and food safety recommends. If you make your own meatballs, ground beef is safe at 160°F, which you’ll find on the USDA’s safe minimum internal temperature chart. To freeze, leave the pasta out and cook it fresh when you reheat.

Creamy Italian meatball soup questions

More meatballs or more pasta?

That’s the question at the end of our video. If you’re on team meatballs, add another half pound. The broth has room for it, and the protein goes up with it.

Do the meatballs need to thaw?

No. Frozen, fully cooked meatballs go straight into the boiling broth and heat through in the 10 minutes the pasta takes.

Can I skip the cream?

You’ll have a tomato meatball soup instead of a creamy one. Still good, just a different bowl.

Ladle it into deep bowls with an extra pinch of parmesan on top, and put a spoon in every one. Forks won’t cut it here.

Filed underSoups

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating