Dump it in. Walk away. 20 free high-protein crockpot dinners + 3 bonus breakfasts.

All recipes

Free ebook

Dump & Go Comfort Food

20 high-protein keto crockpot dinners with freezer packs, plus 3 bonus breakfasts and a two-week plan. Dump it in. Walk away.

You'll also get one new dinner by email every Sunday. Unsubscribe anytime.

Keto Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies

Soft almond flour peanut butter cookies rolled in erythritol and topped with a homemade sugar-free chocolate kiss. Keto Christmas cookies with about 2 g net carbs per cookie.

By Shary Eliot ·NOV 14, 2026 ·Be the first to rate

This post has affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Disclosure

Keto Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies
01Why this one

Every tray of Christmas cookies has one that disappears first, and in a lot of houses it’s the peanut butter blossom. These keto Christmas cookies keep everything people love about it: a soft peanut butter cookie with a sugary-looking crackle on the outside and a little peak of chocolate pressed into the center. The difference is what’s inside. Almond flour, natural peanut butter and erythritol do the work that flour and sugar used to do, and the chocolate kiss on top is one you melt and shape yourself.

Each cookie comes in at about 2 g net carbs. That’s low enough to set out a full plate without doing math every time someone reaches for one.

I cook every recipe in my own kitchen before it goes up here, and this one smells exactly like it should. Peanut butter and warm butter in the oven, then a bowl of melted chocolate on the counter while the cookies cool. If you have ever made the classic version, you’ll know the moment.

Where peanut butter blossoms come from

This cookie has a real birthday, which is rare for a holiday classic. A home baker named Freda Smith from Gibsonburg, Ohio entered it in the 1957 Pillsbury Bake-Off. She called it Black-Eyed Susans back then, and the name it carries today, Peanut Blossoms, came later from Pillsbury. Her cookie didn’t take the grand prize, but it went on to outlast almost everything else from that contest.

The recipe was printed on bags of chocolate kisses for years, so it spread from kitchen to kitchen the easy way: on the back of the package. In 1999 it joined the Bake-Off Hall of Fame, alongside nine other recipes. Today it’s one of the cookies people expect to see in a Christmas tin, right next to the cutouts and the snowballs.

The classic method is simple. Roll the dough in sugar, bake, then press an unwrapped chocolate kiss into each hot cookie so the edges crack around it. That crackle is part of the look.

Low carb Christmas cookies that still look like the original

December is cookie season in a big way. Cookie swaps, teacher gifts, a plate by the door when people stop by. If you eat low carb, it’s also the month where you mostly stand next to the cookie tray and don’t touch it. That’s the reason I wanted a version of this one that sits on the same plate as everyone else’s and doesn’t look like the “diet” option.

So the shape stays the same. The dough gets rolled in granulated erythritol, which bakes up with the same sparkly coat as sugar. The cookie is still soft, still a little cracked on top, and still has that chocolate point in the middle. If you’re building out a whole tray, my raspberry thumbprint Christmas cookies use the same thumbprint idea with jam, and the two look lovely side by side.

How these keto Christmas cookies recipes stay low carb

Most keto Christmas cookies recipes for blossoms run into the same two problems. The first is the kiss. Regular milk chocolate kisses are made with sugar, so the chocolate here is homemade: unsweetened baking chocolate melted with a little butter and powdered erythritol. Let it sit for 15 to 20 minutes after melting and it thickens like frosting. Then a spoonful holds a peak when you lift the spoon away, just like a kiss.

The second problem is the dough. Natural peanut butter is runnier than the sweetened kind, and almond flour has no gluten to hold things together. One egg and a cup and a half of almond flour fix that. If your peanut butter is extra drippy and the dough feels sticky, give it 15 minutes in the fridge before you roll it.

The other trick is timing. Almond flour cookies are fragile when they’re hot. Instead of pressing chocolate into a hot cookie like the original, you let the cookies rest for two minutes, press a little well into each one with the back of a half teaspoon measure, and let them cool all the way. The chocolate goes in once they’re firm.

Since the dough has a raw egg in it, skip the spoon-licking. The FDA says to never eat or taste raw dough or batter, and that goes for this one too. The baked cookie is worth the wait.

One cookie has about 137 calories, 5 g of protein, 12 g of fat and 2 g of net carbs. The recipe card shows the full total carbs, which is higher, because erythritol is counted in that number. Erythritol is a sugar alcohol, and the NIDDK notes that sugar alcohols cause a smaller rise in blood glucose than other carbohydrates, so it gets subtracted when you work out net carbs. The full math is in the recipe notes.

These are a holiday cookie, not a protein snack, and I won’t dress them up as one. They’re rich, so one or two with coffee feels like plenty. If your crew is more of a chocolate chip family, my keto chocolate chip cookies are the everyday cookie for the rest of the year.

A few swaps work well here:

  • Allulose in place of the erythritol. It browns faster, so check the cookies a minute or two early.
  • A monk fruit and erythritol blend, cup for cup, in the dough and for rolling.
  • Natural almond butter for the peanut butter, if someone at the table can’t have peanuts. Make sure everything else on the tray is peanut-free too.
  • Store-bought sugar-free chocolate chips, melted with the butter, instead of the homemade chocolate. Check the label, because the numbers will change.

The nutrition on the card is for the recipe exactly as written.

03At the stove
Keto Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies
The recipe

Keto Peanut Butter Blossom Cookies

Prep
20 MIN
Cook
24 MIN
Total
1 HR 20 MIN
Serves
24

01Ingredients

24 cookies

03Method

Tap a step when it's done. The next one lights up.

0 OF 9 DONE

04Recipe notes

  1. 01Each cookie has about 2 g net carbs and 5 g protein. The card lists total carbs (11 g, sugar alcohols included): about 11.1 g total carbs - 1.9 g fiber - 7.2 g erythritol = about 2.0 g net carbs per cookie. The erythritol is subtracted. The nutrition counts all of the rolling erythritol, although a little stays in the bowl. Use natural peanut butter with only peanuts and salt on the label; sweetened peanut butter adds sugar and changes the numbers. Do not taste the raw dough, it contains a raw egg. Storage: once the chocolate is set, keep the cookies in a sealed container with parchment between layers, up to 3 days in a cool spot or up to 1 week in the fridge. Freeze set cookies on a tray, then pack them in a freezer bag or tin; best within 2 to 3 months. Thaw on the counter for about 20 minutes.

05Nutrition

Per serving
Calories
137
Protein
5G
Net carbs
2G
Fat
12G
Fiber
2G

Net carbs are total carbs minus fiber. Numbers are estimates from the ingredients listed.

Made it?

How did it turn out?

No ratings yet. Tap a star to be the first.

Snap a photo and tag @recipe_smoke1 so I can see how yours came out.

04After dinner

Christmas cookies keto FAQ

Can I use regular peanut butter?

You can, but sweetened peanut butter has added sugar, so the cookie won’t be keto anymore and the numbers on the card won’t match. Look for a jar that lists only peanuts and salt.

Why did my cookies crumble when I pressed the center?

They were still too hot or too warm. Give them the full two minutes on the pan, press gently, and expect a few small cracks at the edges. That’s the classic look.

Are these low carb Christmas cookies good for a cookie exchange?

Yes. They travel well once the chocolate is set. Pack them in a single layer or with parchment between layers, and keep them cool so the chocolate doesn’t smudge.

How many cookies does this make?

24 cookies, about a heaping tablespoon of dough each. One cookie is one serving.

Put them on the plate next to everyone else’s cookies and see if anyone can tell which ones are keto.

Filed underKeto Desserts

Leave a Comment

Recipe Rating